It definitely doesn’t suck to be us, because Avenue Q is celebrating its 12th anniversary this week! The Tony-winning musical originally opened on Broadway on July 31, 2003 and played for 6 years before moving to off-Broadway’s New World Stages. In honor of the hit tuner’s big birthday, we asked you to rank your favorite characters on Culturalist, from Trekkie Monster to Lucy the Slut. The results are in—check out your picks below!

BRIAN

THE BAD NEWS BEARS

LUCY THE SLUT

PRINCETON

GARY COLEMAN

CHRISTMAS EVE

NICKY

TREKKIE MONSTER

KATE MONSTER

ROD